Skip to content

Review

PikaOS - An Easy and Powerful Linux Gaming Distribution

PikaOS - A Debian-based Linux distribution that... really surprised me.

Michele Pelosi 8 min read

In this article
  1. How I discovered it
  2. PikaOS's base
  3. Pros
  4. Cons
  5. Conclusions

How I discovered it

It all started with the problems around Arch Linux's AUR.
I was looking for a new operating system that wouldn't potentially be exposed to similar situations. In reality I hadn't been affected and, most likely, I never would have been: I installed very few packages from the AUR and, in most cases, they were very well-known and actively maintained packages. However, what happened made me think about depending on a community-run repository.

I was looking for a gaming-oriented distribution, but without the "console" philosophy that many distros have been adopting lately. For this reason I ruled out Nobara and Bazzite right from the start: excellent distributions, but too focused on offering a ready-to-use SteamOS-style experience.

The remaining alternatives were mainly CachyOS and PikaOS. CachyOS intrigued me a lot, but since it's still based on Arch it didn't solve the main reason that had pushed me to look elsewhere. PikaOS, on the other hand, was a fairly recent discovery and, over time, turned out to be surprisingly pleasant to use.

PikaOS's base

PikaOS is based on Debian, more precisely on the Sid (Unstable) branch, with the selective addition of some packages from Debian Experimental (mainly desktop environments) and from the DEB Multimedia repositories.
Many people, reading this, will immediately think it's an unreliable or overly unstable choice. In reality, at least in my experience, it was exactly the opposite.

It's worth clarifying one thing: the name "Unstable" shouldn't be understood in the common sense of the word. It doesn't mean the packages are broken or poorly tested, simply that they represent the most recent point of Debian development, before any freeze ahead of a stable release.

What makes PikaOS reliable isn't so much Sid itself, but the work the team does on top of this base: selecting (cherry-picking) packages, gaming-specific patches, optimised builds and an update system designed to avoid the breakages typical of a "pure" rolling release. It's precisely this "curated" approach on top of Sid that allows PikaOS to offer very recent software without exposing the user to the raw instability of the Unstable branch.

The result is a system that receives much more recent software than Debian Stable, while still keeping a good level of reliability thanks to the selection and patching work of the PikaOS team. This compromise is why many people find it an excellent middle ground between Debian Stable and a classic rolling release.

In my experience PikaOS is one of the most stable and least "breakable" distributions I've ever used. The only time I managed to break it was entirely my fault: when I changed graphics cards I decided to remove the NVIDIA drivers without realising that, along with the drivers, several Desktop Environment packages would be removed too... let's just say I hadn't thought it through. 😅

Apart from that episode, the system has always proven extremely stable. Updates have been trouble-free, the system is very smooth and much of the configuration needed for gaming is ready from the very first install. Drivers, firmware and optimisations are already included, avoiding a lot of the manual configuration typical of other distributions.

Pros

There are quite a few pros.

Being based on Debian Sid with selection and patching by the team, PikaOS receives much more up-to-date packages than Debian Stable. In daily use the feeling is very similar to a rolling release: recent kernels, up-to-date Mesa, newer drivers and software generally very close to the latest available versions.

This gives you a distribution with an extremely solid base like Debian, but without giving up up-to-date components, a very important feature especially in Linux gaming, where new versions of the kernel, Mesa, Wine, Proton or graphics drivers can translate into better support for newly released games and higher performance.

In addition, many packages are compiled with specific optimisations (LTO and x86_64 micro-architecture optimisations). PikaOS in fact integrates a series of gaming-specific patches and configurations, as well as updated versions of fundamental components such as Mesa, Gamescope, Proton-GE, Wine-GE and numerous tools used by the Linux gaming ecosystem. The result is a distribution that offers performance very close to CachyOS without giving up the solid Debian infrastructure.

A small note of merit - the package manager

PikaOS uses pikman (yes, I thought it too, you're not the only ones 😄).

The feature that struck me most is the ability to use software from different ecosystems, such as Arch (including the AUR), Fedora and Alpine. Obviously this isn't a "pacman for Debian", nor a direct compatibility layer: it would be impossible to run an Arch package natively on Debian without its specific system libraries.

Technically, pikman works by integrating a containerised subsystem (along the lines of Distrobox / APX) for each requested ecosystem: when you use the --arch/--aur flag, an Arch Linux-based environment is started, inside which the package is downloaded, verified and compiled with makepkg, with its whole native toolchain (gcc, clang, make, ninja, cmake, meson, etc.).

The installed application is not extracted or moved onto the Debian base system — an operation that would break the program because of missing libraries — but keeps living and running inside the isolated container. Pikman then takes care of "exporting" the launchers (the .desktop files), the icons and any wrapper binaries to the Debian host: this way the application appears in the system menu and can be used exactly as if it were installed natively, while in the background it is transparently launched in the Arch environment.

This approach is incredibly clean: it completely isolates the dependencies specific to each ecosystem (Arch, Fedora, Alpine) from the underlying Debian system, avoiding library conflicts (such as differences between glibc versions) and allowing the containers to be managed tidily or removed without the risk of leaving orphaned files or "dirtying" the host system.

Of course, it isn't magic. Some PKGBUILDs rely on patches or hardware-related dependencies of the Arch ecosystem that, while working inside the container, may require deeper integration with the host system (such as specific drivers or systemd system services) that isn't always transparent or immediately available.

Despite this, compatibility for desktop applications and common software is surprisingly high. For most projects the integration process is completely invisible in everyday use.

It's a feature you'll probably use rarely, since PikaOS already has very well-stocked repositories and Flatpak covers most desktop applications. However, when you come across a project available only on the AUR, being able to use the PKGBUILD directly with a simple command, without going crazy writing Debian packages from scratch, is a huge convenience.

Cons

If I really have to find a flaw, I'd say the main one concerns the development team.

PikaOS is maintained by a relatively small group of developers. If you're one of those who place a lot of weight on the size of the community or on having a company behind it, this distribution probably isn't for you.

There is in fact the risk, at least in theory, that the project could slow down or even stop if its few maintainers decided to abandon it. It's a real risk, although at the moment the project continues to be developed steadily.

It must be said, though, that since it's based on Debian, even in the worst-case scenario you wouldn't end up with an unusable system within a few months. The base would still keep receiving updates from Debian; what would be missing would mainly be PikaOS's customisations and specific repositories.

Conclusions

After several months of use I can say that PikaOS really surprised me. I expected an interesting distribution, but I didn't think it would become my main system.

If you're looking for a Linux distribution dedicated to gaming, able to install practically everything by itself, fast, performant and with the NVIDIA drivers already included in the installation ISO, then in my opinion you've found a really interesting candidate.

It manages to combine the solidity of the Debian ecosystem with very up-to-date software, offering an experience that closely resembles a rolling release but with much greater stability than you might expect from simply reading the word Sid.

It isn't a perfect distribution and it will probably never be the best choice for everyone. However, if your goal is to have a machine ready for gaming, with little manual configuration and without giving up recent software, I believe it's one of the most interesting alternatives available today in the Linux landscape.

I'd also like to point out that this is my first review. As you'll have noticed, I prefer to keep things fairly concise (well... I tried 😄) to leave room for the comments section, where I'm always happy to answer questions, doubts or curiosities.

-PikaOS (official wiki)

-Software alternatives (/alternative)

commenti.sh

Comments

Written by , IT specialist writing about privacy, security and open source.